26 Comments
User's avatar
john carr's avatar

And thanks for your beautifully written appreciation.

john carr's avatar

I remember watching this at the time. It was spell-binding. I thought the film good too, though for Gary Oldman to maintain that he hadn't seen the Guinness TV version stretches credulity as his performance is one long tribute.

Jacqueline W's avatar

I thought it was just me who couldn't follow the plot (even reading the book), what a relief! I didn't finally get the whole story until I watched the 2011 film on a wet afternoon during "lockdown" (it didn't need to be wet actually, nothing else to do then of course) a few years ago.

Johan van de Beek's avatar

Tried to wach the movie twice. Could not make any sense of it. Hate deliberate vageness.

Ian Clark's avatar

Great piece - made me go and rewatch (available for a month or so on BBC iPlayer, as I think is the Gary Oldman film)

Wilfred's avatar

It is brilliant. I rewatch it every year. Smiley’s People is just as good imho

Sera's avatar

Le Carré himself gives a wonderful portrait of his friend Alec Guiness in his memoir: “The Pigeon Tunnel”, one of few books which for which I prefer the audiobook, because of Le Carré’s magnificent reading.

As for Guiness being one of the best “of his generation”. Is there a greater actor of any generation? I can’t think of one.

Lou Tilsley's avatar

I have watched the 2011 film but this absolutely makes me want to sit down and invest some time in the series.

C.A. Forbes Author's avatar

Loved TTSP, discovered John Le Carre as a 13 year old, all the complexities of an amazing BBC production, all those actors and I will admit, developed a life long crush on Michael Jayston!

Guy Hearn's avatar

Very good article thank you. I watch TTSS every 4 or 5 years, it’s so superbly done. One of its great strengths is that it works in every medium - book, audiobooks, adaption for radio, 7 hour TV , 2 hour film. And as you say it brings to life the Britain as fading power of the 70s beautifully. And I am really not sure the plot was difficult to follow ? It’s not linear, true, but I was never impossible

Robert Dillinger's avatar

Great column. The book was excellent, this series was excellent. The movie was, to me,, a little short of good, but better than OK. Goldman was great, but the story owed much to peripheral characters, and the movie didn’t give justice to them.

Patrick McAllister's avatar

Book, the film, the series…all brilliant. Smiley’s People is a more than worthy sequel. But - a pretty bleak portrayal of British decline and a changing class structure. We also had Morecambe and Wise:)

ken bledsoe's avatar

surprised you didn't mention gary oldman playing smiley and jackson lamb. and that "Slow Horses" is set in the exact same world as TTSS

Jonny Shire's avatar

An excellent read, thanks!

Georg Elsner's avatar

Great analysis of the whole thing. Book, plot, context, acting, actors, fashions....This was a well written piece. I'd disagree re. Ricky Tarr (Hywell Bennett). Tom Hardy's hair was a joke! Smiley in the later Smiley's people was even better. The interviews were superb....Toby/Hepton; Westerby/Ackland. Dinner with Martindale/Stock was sublime. Medel/Sewel needs a mention. I've watched it over a dozen times.

Promachos's avatar

The film version is one of my favourites and I’ve seen it at least four times, which lead me to track down the tv series. Both excellent, and such a tonic to all the tv writing now for people who are expected to scroll so much they’re barely paying attention.

Douglas Quaid's avatar

Nearly shed a tear at that last paragraph. Great writing, thank you.